| Richard Balzhizer | FB | 1952 | Chemical Engineering |
| James Orwig | OT | 1955, 1957 | LS&A, History |
| Robert Timberlake | QB | 1964 | LS&A, Sociology |
| David Fisher | FB | 1966 | Engineering |
| Richard Vidmer | QB | 1966 | LS&A Pre-Law |
| James Mandich | TE | 1969 | |
| Phil Seymour | DE | 1970 | Economics |
| Bruce Elliott | DB | 1971 | History |
| William Hart | OG | 1972 | LS&A |
| Kirk Lewis | OG | 1974 | Pre-Med |
| Norm Betts | TE | 1981 | LS&A, Pre-Dental |
| Robert Thompson | LB | 1982 | LS&A, Pre-Med |
| Stefan Humphries | OG | 1982, 1983 | Engineering |
| Clay Miller | OT | 1985 | LS&A |
| Ken Higgins | WR | 1985 | LS&A |
| Rob Renes | NT | 1999 | LS&A, Secondary Education |
|
| |
| Second Team Selections |
| John Wangler | QB | 1980 | LS&A, Psychology |
| Bubba Paris | OT | 1980 | Education |
| Norm Betts | TE | 1980 | LS&A, Pre-Dental |
| Ed Muransky | DT | 1981 | Pharmacy |
| Marc Milia | C | 1993 | LS&A, Biology |
| Chris Hutchinson | DL | 1992 | Kinesiology, Movement Science |
| Jon Jansen | OT | 1998 | Kinesiology, Teacher Education |
| Rob Renes | NT | 1998 | LS&A, Secondary Education |
| Adam Finley | Punter | 2004 | Bio-Medical Engineering |
