On U-M’s campus, meanwhile, protesters were marching and sitting-in to oppose the Vietnam War, support civil rights, and to speak out about a variety of issues. Many local police officials took issue with everything from their haircuts to their clothing to their politics, while more than a few protesters referred to police as “pigs.” The South University Riots of June 1969 were the culmination of the anger and frustration: four nights of confrontations between local law enforcement and portions of Ann Arbor’s counterculture population.
“It was commented on in the Michigan Daily and the local papers that the police were able to synchronize five different police agencies and riot gear to crack down on a public demonstration on South U that by all accounts had started pretty peacefully,” Templeton says. “But it wasn’t until the sixth murder, I think that same month, June 1969, that they established a task force for five different local police agencies to work on the murders.
“I know it’s a little bit apples to oranges, but people at the time definitely noticed and thought, ‘wow, they can organize for these kinds of political displays or challenges to power, but when it comes to murders of young women, they’re all fighting among each other.’”
The Hippies Weren’t Surprised
That frustration comes through in the documentary: Why wasn’t more done to organize the law enforcement agencies earlier in the process? Why wasn’t Collins considered a more serious suspect after the second murder? Was there a connection between the treatment of Collins and his uncle’s position with the state police? If police were less focused on campus protests and anti-war sit-ins, could they have organized a more successful murder investigation?
Yet Templeton is even-handed and nuanced in his narrative. He interviewed former Sheriff Douglas Harvey at length, and the larger-than-life figure appears on screen at length in 1969, defending his department’s role in the investigations.
Most sympathetic of all the law enforcement figures featured or mentioned in the film is Larry Mathewson, who was an EMU police officer in the late 1960s and who played an integral role in the eventual arrest of John Norman Collins for one of the murders in August 1969.
Mathewson told Templeton, “the public has a right to know more” about these crimes and the time period in which they took place. He speaks in the documentary about his suspicions of Collins’ links to other murders.
The documentary, the book The Michigan Murders, and numerous newspaper articles have more to say about Collins’ possible role in the other murders, whether he had accomplices, how much Collins’ uncle may have been aware of, a link to a murder in California.
For Templeton, one of the reasons for telling this story was that only one of the murders was ever officially solved. Collins was convicted in 1970 of killing Beineman, the final known victim, in his state police corporal uncle’s basement. The other victims’ families never knew definitively who was responsible for their murders.
Legendary Ann Arbor counterculture leader John Sinclair sums up the disconnect in the documentary: “I don’t think anybody that was a hippie was much surprised to find that it was a person with police connections. We were quite relieved that they had caught this guy, and the fact that he was related to these state police characters kind of explained why it had taken so long.”